CASE STUDY / WHOLESALE BEVERAGES / UNITED STATES

Better sending.
Better replies.
Real buyer interest.

How we helped an anonymous wholesale tea supplier recover a struggling US cold outreach campaign by combining custom prospect research with unusually deep email infrastructure troubleshooting.

Client identity withheld · Ongoing engagement · No purchased lead lists in this campaign

REPLY RATE / BEFORE & AFTER

~1.1% early period

THE INVESTIGATION
6.8%

Measured in a later seven-day campaign snapshot. The initial and later percentages are from different reporting windows.

Wholesale teaUS mainland / excluding AK & HI
~1.1%Initial reply rate
Earlier campaign period
6.8%Step-level reply rate
Selected 7-day period
59.3%Positive share of replies
Selected 7-day period
~5KEmails every week
Primary prospecting only

01 / THE ENGAGEMENT

A simple product.
A complex market.

Anonymous client. Actual campaign. Results presented with their reporting periods intact.

Our client sells tea wholesale. Their buyers aren't one neatly defined list of enterprises: they're independent coffee shops, boba shops and bubble tea businesses across the contiguous United States.

To reach those buyers, this particular campaign needed far more than uploading a generic spreadsheet into an email tool. We built its prospect data in-house, ran its outreach, and kept examining what happened after each email was sent.

That final part became decisive. Early reply rates were disappointing, even though part of the sending operation was already performing noticeably better than the rest.

02 / PROSPECTING

The right businesses.
Not a purchased list.

For this specific wholesale tea engagement, we sourced and collected prospective buyers ourselves, then researched and enriched the records in-house. The result was a campaign-specific prospect base focused on the places actually positioned to stock or serve the product.

This was our approach for this client. It is not a claim that every Incredible Outreach engagement uses the same sourcing workflow.

03 / THE PROBLEM

The same campaign.
Two very different signals.

Early overall performance hovered around 1.1% in an initial period. Looking deeper into mailbox segments during the investigation, we found a pronounced gap between Microsoft and Google Workspace senders. That gap changed where we looked for the problem.

Microsoft mailboxes / ~40% of pool~6%

Observed reply rate in the diagnostic comparison.

Microsoft sending routeGraph API
Google Workspace / ~60% of pool~1%

Observed reply rate in the diagnostic comparison.

Google sending routeSMTP

Segment figures are approximate observations from the investigation, not a single weighted calculation of the separately reported ~1.1% initial overall rate. The mailbox pool composition is approximate.

04 / BEHIND THE SEND BUTTON

We spent two months looking where most campaign dashboards stop.

Instead of cycling through more lists and rewriting everything, we investigated the email transport itself.

01 / ISOLATE

Compare the senders

We examined the uneven results from Microsoft and Google Workspace accounts in the same operation.

02 / INVESTIGATE

Read below the dashboard

We dug into message headers, sending IP behavior and routing, including differences between Graph API and SMTP sending paths.

03 / CHALLENGE

Pressure-test the hypothesis

We worked through the issue with the sending provider's support and experienced deliverability practitioners, focusing on suspected IPv6-related routing behavior.

04 / CHANGE

Move the sending platform

We moved the campaign from Plusvibe to Instantly while retaining its leads, mailboxes and wider campaign setup.

What changed?
The sending path.

Reply performance improved after the platform move, with both mailbox groups performing better. The outcome strongly supported our infrastructure diagnosis, though a platform migration alone does not prove one specific IPv6 mechanism was the only cause.

05 / REPORTED CAMPAIGN PERFORMANCE

Measured replies.
Genuine interest.

In the October 27–November 2, 2026 reporting window, the primary campaign sent 3,324 emails and recorded a 6.8% step-level reply rate. Of those step-level replies, 59.3% were classified as positive. That is the signal this campaign was built to generate: buyers interested in trying a wholesale product.

An editorial summary of selected first-step campaign figures: approximately 1.1% initially, 6.8% reply rate and 59.3% positive share of replies in the later seven-day window, with about 5,000 emails sent weekly in the primary campaign.
Selected performance figures from internal campaign reporting. The initial and later reply rates reflect different periods. This is a data summary, not an unmodified platform screenshot; internal operational fields are intentionally omitted.

06 / PRIMARY PROSPECTING CAMPAIGN

The goal is qualified interest. Not maximum volume.

Every week, this client's primary prospecting campaign sends approximately 5,000 tailored emails to relevant coffee shops, cafés and bubble tea businesses. The campaign's purpose is to find businesses interested in trying the wholesale tea offering and begin a conversation.

We could send much more. We choose targeted research, thoughtful outreach and a high proportion of interested replies instead. The results reflect an active, recurring campaign, not a one-off promotion.

~5,000

emails sent weekly
Primary campaign

First-touch

Prospecting and opening interested conversations

What is counted. The weekly send volume refers only to the primary prospecting campaign. Follow-up campaigns and later-stage subsequences are separate and not included in this figure. Sales outcomes happen downstream and are not being claimed here.

07 / WHAT THIS CASE DEMONSTRATES

Campaign performance isn't just a copywriting problem.

01 / PRECISION

Targeting built for the buyer.

For this client, prospect sourcing and enrichment were handled in-house, so the campaign could focus on relevant US beverage businesses rather than an undifferentiated third-party list.

02 / DIAGNOSIS

Infrastructure is part of the work.

We investigated sending routes, IP behavior and email headers instead of treating a weak aggregate reply rate as the full explanation.

03 / DISCIPLINE

Change a variable. Watch the result.

Moving the campaign while retaining its leads and mailboxes gave us a practical test of the sending environment. It preceded a substantial recovery in replies.

READY TO TALK OUTBOUND?

Your outreach deserves more than a dashboard review.

Tell us who you need to reach and what a qualified conversation looks like. We'll talk through whether managed outbound is a fit.

Book a 30 minute callDirect booking · No client information disclosed